ANTM 12.04 “New York’s Finest” Live Blog
March 18, 2009 by Erin Balser
Welcome to tonight’s live blog of America’s Next Top Model. Tonight, the girls learn how to strut their stuff on the catwalk and do their best to portray New York’s finest in a team photo shoot!

The CW © 2009 The CW Network, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Full live blog and who goes home below the jump!
Original Air Date: March 18, 2009
Challenge: Runway show
Challenge winner: Natalie
Photo Shoot: New York City personalities
Called First: Sandra
Eliminated: Nijah
NO SPOILERS IN THE LIVE DISCUSSION PLEASE.
Questions
Did Natalie deserve to win the challenge?
Do you like Teyona’s new look?
Was Tahlia’s photo as great as the judges claimed?
Was Allison as terrible as the judges claimed?
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
Who is Celia ganging up on in the previews for next week?














Did Natalie deserve to win the challenge?
no! i really dislike her. she’s a total bore, and not even a nice person while doing so.
Do you like Teyona’s new look?
i didn’t notice that much of a difference, but the jheri curl is less noticeable so i guess i like it better now.
Was Tahlia’s photo as great as the judges claimed?
no! just because she’s smiling, they ignore the fact that she looked like a chipmunk?
Was Allison as terrible as the judges claimed?
it was bad, but not that bad…
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
i liked aminat’s and fo’s best. sandra’s and celia’s was good also. i think natalie and teyona and tahlia had the worst one, and possibly the easiest concept. (p.s. since when are tourists new york city’s elite?)
Who is Celia ganging up on in the previews for next week?
hopefully tahlia. lock her out of the house if it’s necessary!
Did Natalie deserve to win the challenge?
I think Celia should have been given the win because she did everything that was expected of her. Natalie did that stupid twirl which ruined it, but I guess they liked her confidence. One thing is for sure, though: she sucks at taking her photo. So I don’t see her going too far.
Do you like Teyona’s new look?
Much better than the 80s ‘do!
Was Tahlia’s photo as great as the judges claimed?
Not really, but not the worst either.
Was Allison as terrible as the judges claimed?
She looked super cute, but didn’t do what was asked of her. Unless she portrayed a super cute rich snob? Hmm, I guess that doesn’t work…
Whose photo was the best?
Sandra, Aminat and Fo
The worst?
Nijah and Natalie
Who is Celia ganging up on in the previews for next week?
I don’t know, but it better be juicy!!
Did Natalie deserve to win the challenge?
I think natalie is very confident. You could definitley see it off her face plus her walk was the best. TAHLIA HAD THE WORST WALK AND SHOULD HAVE BEEN ELIMINATED AT THE RUNWAY CAUSE SHE IS ANNOYING.
Do you like Teyona’s new look?
I really didn’t notice the difference.
Was Tahlia’s photo as great as the judges claimed?
Tahlia is clearly the most annoying girl this cycle for me. Yes her message about her scars is good but still. Her photo sucked IMO. Anyone could have done that pose. Gosh she should haven’t been called early. Oh well her annoying self is going after next week. Next week I feel Kortnie is going.
Was Allison as terrible as the judges claimed?
No She was soooo Kawaii (cute)!!! But she didn’t seem like a snobby rich girl. But she was a very Kawaii rich girl. She shouldnt have been in the bottom two. I feel Kortnie should have been in the bottom two with Ninja (Nijah).
Whose photo was the best?
Aminat and FO!!!!!! There pic was the best out of the bunch. Aminat should have been First call out. Sandra’s photo SUCKED!!!!
The worst?
KORTNIE AND NINJA (NIJAH)
Who is Celia ganging up on in the previews for next week?
I think Natalie since people clearlly don’t like her. Or maybe Sandra. if it’s allison i will definitley not like her anymore!
Did Natalie deserve to win the challenge?
yeah she had the best walk and she is the most modelesque…the twirl might not have worked but at least she had the confidence to take a risk
Do you like Teyona’s new look?
i don’t like her look period. she is freaky, and her weave starts way too far back on her forehead. she looks like an alien
Was Tahlia’s photo as great as the judges claimed?
no that was just a sympathy compliment cause she sucks so bad. i am so over that whiny little bitch
Was Allison as terrible as the judges claimed?
no i thought it was really cute
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
aminat and fo’s for sho. i don’t get the hype on sandra’s pic…she looked like she had a birds nest on her head and i so don’t get the blonde thing…
Who is Celia ganging up on in the previews for next week?
i hope its either sandra or tahlia…i cannot stand those bitches