ANTM 11.12 “Good Times & Windmills” Live Blog
November 12, 2008 by Erin Balser
Welcome to the live blog for the twelfth episode of America’s Next Top Model. Tonight, its down to the final four and girls let loose in Amsterdam!
Original Air Date: November 12, 2008
Below the cut is who stays, who goes, full recap and discussion questions!
Challenge: Commercial audition
Challenge Winner: Marjorie
Photo Shoot: Windmills
Guest Judge: Ann Shoket
Called First: Analeigh
Eliminated: Marjorie
Questions
What did you think of the challenge?
Did Marjorie deserve to win the challenge?
Should Marjorie have been reprimanded for her drinking?
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
Who is going to win it all?
FAKE FATIMA, YO A** HAS BEEN EXPOSED. DON’T COME BACK NEXT WEEK COS I’LL RIP YOU INTO PIECES….
What did you think of the challenge?
i think it sounded cool and not fake for once when they first talked about it and said they would be auditioning, but then they brought out the treadmill and it turned into typical america’s next top model lameness.
Did Marjorie deserve to win the challenge?
ehhh. she wins most improved
Should Marjorie have been reprimanded for her drinking?
maybe, because a lot of young people watch this show and probably got the wrong message, but if they never talked to any of the other people who were smoking other things besides ciggarettes/drinking, so it wouldn’t be fair if they did.
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
loved mckey’s and analeigh’s.
Who is going to win it all?
mckey, i hope
yaaaaaaaaaaaaa! shes gone marjore see ya sam or analighe sough have won- best pic was mckeys -worst marjore lush- who gonna win it all samantha a lot of winners are in the bmt 2 for the final 3
not for nothing, but if people are seriously fighting over whether an online identity is real or not, then they need to find other things to do.
anyways, i’m glad marjorie went, and i would love for analeigh to win it. she’s so calm and a chill girl (from what i can see)
Who is going to win it all?
Hmm.. i’d like to see analeigh to win. Mckey would have been a great model, but i don’t know.. somehow she’s lack with personality, playing sweet and dumb. Sam, she takes good pictures.. but just like tyra said, she doesn’t walk, talk and breathe as a model.. analeigh, she has it all balance.. even her face not as strong as mckey.. but definitely not samantha to win! or it’s gonna be the 2′nd whitney.. ahahaha…
hollywood bs, the more you badtalk analeigh the more i realize how jealous you are that she’s doing better than mckey. how very infantile of you. stop it, please? k. thx.
hollywood bs, the more you badtalk analeigh the more i realize how jealous you are that she’s doing better than mckey. how very infantile of you. its truly annoying. soo.. stop it, please? k. thx.
i’va said analeigh from the very beginning, so i’m going to stick with that. and i do find her very likable. the others… not so much.
@ Rachel
why shd I be jealous of Analeigh? it’s a modeling competition and we pick our favorites depending on how good we think they as models.
Analeigh to me is commercial and amateur. I can never picture booking high profile campaigns like Mollie Sue or Elyse; campaigns like Diesel, Sony, or high brand cosmetic lines. To me, she’ll be stuck more in the L.A commercial market: toothpaste, low end jewelry, tacky magazines etc. You know, Saleisha’s territory.
Mckey, on the other hand, is the exact opposite. She has an elegance and effortlessness about her that would permit her to do any kind of job. Even one of the designers in Armsterdam said he’ll book her in a second.
That’s my opinion and I’m entitled to it. So since you prefer Analeigh does that make you jealous of Mckey? so a preference automatically means jealousy? who’s the infant and immature one now? think before you speak, it’ll do you some good.
When Tyra said something about Mckey’s joker smile I was like, yes, that is exactly what it looks like! In a good way I think. She has a different look, not “pretty”. She will do well.
Did anyone else think the photo shoot was a little unfair? Mckey got so much environment to work with, she could use the windmill and the chain and a rake in her poses! And everyone else had open space and just the rake. Yes, she had an amazing photo, but I think if everyone else had the same amount as she did to work with, maybe they could have done better.
@ Andi i totally agree! Mckey had a lot more to work with! And I didnt even see marjorie having a rake at all!
I don’t think that majorie should have gone this week. She has the biggest model potential. I don’t know why this show is always trying to get rid of the best models and leave the worst. The three girls left…? they are all beautiful and that’s it. I don’t see a model. And in my opinion they are all boring, especially Mckey!
I thought the photo shoot was unfair also. To give McKey all those props and not give Marjorie anything.
But it’s worth it to point out that they have had other inconsistencies. e.g. In the Jeremy Scott show, McKey was the only one that had to wear a curtain rod!
What did you think of the challenge?
It would have been cute as an actual commercial, but was it just a practice? I don’t know…
Did Marjorie deserve to win the challenge?
I thought Sam did a pretty good job, but I guess they liked the awkwardness of Marjorie’s.
Should Marjorie have been reprimanded for her drinking?
No, she was just having fun. I think Americans are WAY too conservative when it comes to social drinking. Lighten up!
Whose photo was the best?
Sam
The worst?
They were all good!
Who is going to win it all?
McKey or Analeigh