ANTM 11.04 “You’re Beautiful, Now Change” Live Blog
September 17, 2008 by Erin Balser
Welcome to the liveblog of Cycle 11 of America’s Next Top Model. Today is MAKEOVER DAY! I’m super-excited and hope you are too! I’ll be recapping the show as it happens, and you can follow along and join in on the conversation.
Episode: 11.04 You’re Beautiful, Now Change
Original Air Date: September 17, 2008
Below the cut is who stays, who goes, full recap and discussion questions!
Challenge: Covergirl 30-second spot
Challenge Winner: Hannah
Photo Shoot: Swimsuit
Guest Judge: Susan Holmes
Called First: Elina
Eliminated: Brittany
Questions
Whose makeover was the best? The worst?
How do you feel about Elina’s makeover?
Did Hannah deserve to win the Covergirl challenge?
Should Elina support her “I hate my mother” claims? Or are they nobody’s business?
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
Did Elina deserve to be called first?
Whose makeover was the best? The worst?
The best, i think samanthas.. i loved how it looked on her! worst… at first i thought elina, but now i am getting use to it.. i think worst is Sheenas…
How do you feel about Elina’s makeover? At first didnt like it, after the picture.. it looked better.
Did Hannah deserve to win the Covergirl challenge? Yes.. she sounded and looked cute!
Should Elina support her “I hate my mother” claims? Or are they nobody’s business? I think that she knows what she is saying… You would have to be her to understand, so there is no point to say more.
Whose photo was the best? The worst? Best… Lauren, worst… i did not like Joselyns.. her nose looked completly different.
Did Elina deserve to be called first? I think 2nd… laurens was better
Whose makeover was the best? The worst?
i liked samantha’s! the worst was i guess lauren brie’s, because even though it wasn’t that bad, it was so subtle it was pointless.
How do you feel about Elina’s makeover?
i loved how it look after it was cut and styled at the salon, but it didn’t look the same again after which was disappointing
Did Hannah deserve to win the Covergirl challenge?
definitely, she rocked it. her small-town-alaska background was charming, in the challenge at least.
Should Elina support her “I hate my mother” claims? Or are they nobody’s business?
it’s her business, but she chose to put it out there and say that she hates her mother, so if the other girls ask why, she should say so. if she tells them to bugger off, she’s an arse because if it was her secret, she wouldn’t have said anything.
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
loved lauren brie’s! and samantha’s, and mckey’s.
Did Elina deserve to be called first?
ehhhh. maybe not first…her photo was good and she did work the new hair, but i dont think her photo was the best of the group
I love McKey, Samantha and Brittanny’s makeover. Marjorie’s too.
But I HATE Sheena’s, Hannah’s and Clark.
those are so wrong. they look better before the makeover.
Whose makeover was the best?
Samantha
The worst?
Isis because she looks exactly the same as she did before and she’s UGLY!!
Oh, and Hannah. They should have added a punch of colour to her hair. The mousy brown hair they gave her pales her out. And the cut! OMG, the cut is horrendous! It looks like Nykeisha’s (sp).
How do you feel about Elina’s makeover?
I really like it. It softens her features, which I wanted to see done. She looked too harsh with the dark hair before. I like this look better. I just wish they would have kept her natural hair. All the weave has got to itch and sweat, no??
Did Hannah deserve to win the Covergirl challenge?
Yes, she was a natural at selling the product. She was adorable. I just wish she had a different haircut, though!
Should Elina support her “I hate my mother” claims? Or are they nobody’s business?
They’re nobody’s business. For all we know her mother could be abusive to her, whether it’s mental or physical. Obviously there is some pain going on and people shouldn’t judge her because of that.
Whose photo was the best?
Elina. She looked so soft and pretty
The worst?
Isis. She had that one pose through out the entire film. I was surprised she wasn’t in the bottom 2. Have I mentioned that she’s UGLY??
Did Elina deserve to be called first?
Yes, she did a good job. I’m rooting for her as she seems to be the only one who looks like a model at this point. I must say that I’m so disappointed in this cycle. None of these girls catch my interest. And Tyra’s overacting is painful to watch. I fast forwarded through that entire segment. I’m starting to get turned off by ANTM. I hope next cycle will improve. Don’t get me wrong, I’m still going to watch this cycle, but I’m not as excited about it as I normally am.
Whose makeover was the best?the worst?
The best makeover that i liked was either Sam or Mckey. Worst i think is Hannah.
How do u feel about elina’s makeover?
At first i was like wtf!! But then when i saw the picture i was like wow!!!
Did hannah the covergirl challenge?
I do i like hannah she iz super cute.
Should Elina support her “I hate my mother” claims? Or are they nobody’s business?
I really can’t say something about this. I say you would have to be her sibling or her to understand
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
The best pic was laurie brie’s. Worst was brittany’s and joselyn’s hated both of their pics.
Did Elina deserve to be called first?
I think Laurie should’ve been called first.
Whose makeover was the best? The worst?
I thought the best makeover was either Mckey’s, Clark’s, Lauren’s, or Samantha’s. They did the same thing to Lauren as they did to Anya, and I really like it! Samnthat’s hair is good, but it almost looks like a wig that doesn’t fit. I didn’t like Marjorie’s at all! It makes her look mousy and not modelesque. They should’ve gone with long flowy blond hair. She remind me of Sarah from Cycle 8 now, who I didn’t like at all.Sheena’s is weird too, Tyra said it would be like hers and we knew that was bad because Tyra’s hair can be pretty wack!
How do you feel about Elina’s makeover?
It looked bad at first, but now I kinda of like it. There’s too much hoopla about it.
Did Hannah deserve to win the Covergirl challenge?
Yeah. she had the Covergirl personality and ad libbed better than the rest. She got all the info in.
Should Elina support her “I hate my mother” claims? Or are they nobody’s business?
She has a hard time opening up, so she had a hard time defending herself. But Brittany was bothering me soooo much. She doesn’t understand that some people live in a family that doesn’t support or love you. They give you things, but things aren’t all you want.
Whose photo was the best? The worst?
The best- Lauren, McKey, Elina. The worst- Joslyn, Brittany, Isis, Marjorie.
Did Elina deserve to be called first?
No. I think there were at least two better photos. But the judges felt bad. It was pretty but not stunning.
A few thoughts: Lauren has gotten ZERO screen time all season, I hope I get to know her better. Analeigh is like Lisa from C9 in how she thinks too much. Though I hated Lisa and love Analeigh. SOOOO excited for next week!